Sam Rainer's 7 P's: A Turnaround Checklist for the Declining Church

If you are reading this from a church that has been stuck for a while, let me say something before we get to the checklist: you are not failing. Somewhere between 65 and 90 percent of churches need some form of revitalization, and roughly six of every ten have plateaued or declined. If your average weekly attendance is under one hundred, your church is normal. That is not a verdict. It is company.

And here is the promise we build everything on: if God can save any person, he can save any church. Most congregations under 100 are not fresh plants chasing their first fifty people. They are existing churches that need turning around. That is honest, and it is also full of hope. Sam Rainer gives us a memorable, workable way through it: seven P's. Let me walk you through them the way I would over coffee.

Before the checklist: get honest about the path

Before you run a single step, make one strategic decision. Plot your church on the life-cycle curve (birth, growth, maturity, aging, decline) and choose one honest path: Complete and Bless (hand your assets to a strong ministry if the church is in late decline), Renew and Reinvest (turn around a church that is merely aging), or Continue and Expand (build on peak vitality). Not every church should attempt renewal, and not every aging church should quit. The 7 P's are for the church God is calling to renew.

One more foundation: personal transformation precedes congregational transformation. You and your key leaders change first, then the church can. This is doable. In one two-year renewal process, 128 leaders began and 126 finished. Turnaround is not a fantasy. It is a sequence.

The 7 P's, one at a time

Rainer frames the whole checklist with the "three knows": know yourself, know your church, know your community. Keep those in view as you work.

1. Priorities. Discern what is most urgent using the simple equation: Outward plus Upward equals Onward. A church moving outward in mission and upward in worship and prayer moves onward in growth. The flip side is the diagnosis behind most decline: inward churches always decline. And be plain about this: your church will not grow larger with the oldest generation alone.

2. Pace. Ask how fast you can actually lead change. Map resistance across four groups: older versus younger members, and those who arrived before versus after you. You cannot lead change faster than your most resistant decisive bloc will tolerate. Pace your changes to where the resistance actually sits.

3. Perspective. Are your expectations properly aligned? This is a read on discouragement intensity. Unrealistic timelines burn out good leaders. Realistic ones keep them in the game.

4. People. Rate your congregation's true capacity to move forward: Low, Average, High, or Unusual. Most decline-stage churches overestimate their capacity and exhaust their leaders. Be honest here before you set any goal.

Put this into practice, free

Create your free 100 Strong account to turn ideas like these into a clear plan. Track your weekly numbers, get a personalized next step, and walk the proven path to 100+ members. No cost, ever.

Create my free account

5. Place. Is your building ready to receive people? Have five longtime members and five newer or outside people walk through and rate the facility. You will hear things longtime eyes stopped seeing years ago.

6. Purpose. Shift the church to an outward focus, and measure it with the conversion ratio: average weekly attendance divided by yearly conversions. A healthy target is 20 to 1 or better. The U.S. average is 85 to 1, which tells us most "growth" is transfer and biological, not new disciples. Give every member a personal goal: reach one person every six months.

7. Pathway. Name the single most realistic next step as a Mid Holy Audacious Goal (MHAG). Not a moonshot, not timid maintenance. A mid-sized, faith-stretching goal sized to your real capacity.

Diagnose your type before you prescribe

Dying churches decline for different reasons, and the cure follows the cause. Roughly 40 percent are Geriatric (an aging congregation), 25 percent are Great Omission (they simply stopped reaching out), 15 percent are Ex-neighborhood (the community around the building changed), 12 percent are War-torn (conflict drained the vitality), and 8 percent are Mismatched (the leadership does not fit the people). Name yours honestly. A war-torn church needs reconciliation; a great-omission church needs a fresh outward push.

Make regained ground stick

Any turnaround needs structure to hold its gains. Rainer names three musts: a new-member class, clear doctrine paired with high expectations, and a real process of discipleship. Without these, you win people and lose them again.

The math is encouraging. Win 20 people a year and retain half, and you can double in about ten years. That is roughly seven percent net growth annually. Compare that to winning 50 with only ten percent retention, which nets just five and falls below normal attrition. Steady beats splashy.

What to do next

Start with prayer, not a strategy memo. Then do your own renewal work before you ask the church to change. Make the honest path-choice. Diagnose your type. Then run the 7 P's as your work plan and install the three musts. And stay an optimist on purpose: every leader must be an optimist, because in a turnaround, hope is a discipline, not a mood. Re-measure once a year and let the trend, not one hard season, set the tone. If you want a clearer read on where you stand, our /assessment can help you locate your minimum factor.

Your challenge this week

Calculate your conversion ratio. Divide your average weekly attendance by the number of conversions in the last twelve months. Write the number down, compare it to the 20-to-1 target, and let it become your honest starting line for Purpose.